I suppose most folks go to movies for the fantasy of it all, so it only makes sense that V for Vendetta ranks with the top video rentals for a liberal oasis like Bellingham, WA. V gets the left-leaning among us all pumped for that moment when the masses recognize the government for what it is - fascism, according to the film’s aesthetic - and surge to overthrow the State. Too bad this revolution is led by a computer-generated cartoon.
This week we here at Film is Truth acquire a DVD of Lizzie Borden’s Born in Flames, my favorite film of all time… for political purposes, anyway. Released in 1983, Flames precedes V for Vendetta by twenty years, and features a revolution made, not by cartoons or Hollywood actors, but real people. Or to be more exact, real women: black women, white women, butch, femme, working class, middle class, young and old, sex workers and social workers, artists and theorists, activists, slack-tivists and butt-crack-tivists (by which I mean to suggest this films got some nudity). Like V, Born in Flames imagines a revolution targeted against an authoritarian government, but this time it’s not a fascist state, but the State itself that’s the target.
Here’s how it goes down. Flames is ingeniously set ten years after a socialist revolution in America, and while the labor movement is apparently in power, women and people of color are – surprise, surprise – still treated like crap. The film follows the efforts of various factions of women to fight back against the discrimination and violence they face in their everyday lives. From the armed self-defense of the Women’s Army, to the broadcasts of Phoenix Radio and Radio Regazza, direct action becomes the only effective course of action in face of the hollow promises of social democracy (some – like me - would call this sort of thing anarchism).
Through it all, Born in Flames becomes a veritable catalog of issues that real-world American radicals are always faced with. Never mind that it was released the year I was born (1983); its relevance to today is one of the most striking things about it. No other film that I know of mixes issues of anti-racism, anti-hierarchical organizing, armed struggle, anti-sexism, working class and queer politics, theory vs. action, State repression, internationalism, media (both corporate and alternative) in the same way. And it doesn’t hurt that the soundtrack kicks ass – a sweet as hell mix of early punk and dub. The theme song alone will be stuck in your head for days, and you’ll love it (“Borrrrrrrrrn in Flaaaa-ames…. Bornnnn in Flaaa-ames…”).
Maybe the reason it feels so authentic is that Flames itself emerged out of radical feminist circles in NYC in the early 1980s. Director Borden interweaves her fictional characters into real political demonstrations, and puts real newscasts to use in her fictional narrative. Activists themselves constitute the cast, giving it a documentary feel while reminding us all the same that the “act” in activist unfortunately has nothing to do with acting (they still manage to act Natalie Portman under the table. IMHO.).
Some might find the film’s pace and inability to resolve a lot of issues irritating. This ain’t no Hollywood film, and for a lot of viewers that might make for a painful viewing experience. Unlike the comic book choreography of V for Vendetta, much of the “action” in Flames simply consists of debates over proper tactics, stuff like violence versus non-violence. Where V is pure fantasy, resolving its plot in an over-the-top revolution, where all the cards fall into place, Flames puts its sci-fi conventions to use in asking barbed questions, at daggers drawn.
Born in Flames is most humble too, more than aware of its inability to resolve everything it is putting to you. How else to explain its explosive, open-ended - and inflammatory – finale? “We are born in flaaaaaaaaaaames” wails the sound track. Now that we’re born, the film leaves it up to us to start living again. And that’s right where the power belongs – in the of the hands of those who lack it (not fools like me, I should note, who are up to their neck in privilege). So rent this film if you have a fist that needs raising.